Opinion: Stand Your Ground is Legal Murder
In 'Stand Your Ground' states like Florida, individuals have "no duty to retreat." Stand Your Ground laws don't just give you a chance to defend yourself using lethal force, it gives the legal green light to use it as your first option. Stand Your Ground does not just apply as a way to avoid punishing self-defense, but it encourages it. It doesn't just allow lethal force as a last resort, but as a first resort. In giving private citizens no duty to even attempt to protect themselves non-violently, the government unwittingly gives people the right to kill, even when it may not have been absolutely necessary, which is the only time self-defense should be lethal. Some may argue that if you're breaking the law you forfeit your right to safety, but swiping some gummies from a convenience store or vandalizing a truck should not warrant a death penalty. It is up to the justice system to award punishment, and anyone who argues otherwise is blatantly disregarding the legal system that we have based our country's justice on. You should only shoot someone if you fear for your life and see no other way. Otherwise, you should not feel as though there would be no consequence to killing someone who has wronged you, which is what Stand Your Ground Laws supplies: the ability to kill someone, even if they weren't going to necessarily hurt you.
https://www.cnn.com/2018/08/03/opinions/stand-your-ground-law-racial-violence-opinion-love/index.html
I agree with your perspective that stand your ground laws are not really functioning in the way that they are meant to be and were created to be. While I don't think it should be justified for someone to kill another person I do not know what another answer to the situation might be. If someone's life is currently being put at danger because to another person I think that they should obviously be allowed to protect themselves, but I just can't decide to what means.
ReplyDeleteWith the Stand your Ground laws, I believe that these laws should only protect people in last resort scenarios. Shooting at someone will always yield a major risk of death, so if ones life is not absolutely in danger, then the laws should not apply. I agree with your opinion on the laws, and the Stand Your Ground case that we studied that occurred in Florida was almost a flaw in our justice system.
ReplyDelete